SC2SEA.com - Starcraft 2 SEA eSports Community Site

pikk0n · Mon, 13th-Jun-2011, 9:04 PM

Thanks Benji. Love the tiebreaker rule.

Loving this game so far! Would add to your reputation but apparently I need to spread the rep around before i can add more rep to you. :S I do not get that....

GGnoRe · Mon, 13th-Jun-2011, 9:26 PM

but musta u lynched me on NA. =( a fellow town! so i shall lynch u rawr.

nard · Mon, 13th-Jun-2011, 9:50 PM

free kill on mafia so early... lol
deathsfang... didnt know u played for the other team... *ahem*

Next_rim · Mon, 13th-Jun-2011, 9:50 PM

I LOLED SO MUCH, the lover thing is pure awesomeness

mustapusta · Mon, 13th-Jun-2011, 9:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GGnoRe

but musta u lynched me on NA. =( a fellow town! so i shall lynch u rawr.

Sorry about the town lynch lol.i'm just an average mafia player

LennX · Mon, 13th-Jun-2011, 11:33 PM

So mustapusta what is your defence for winning the tiebreaker? haha
I think all of us are going to lynch you next unless the informant steps in really fast and save your butt :P

mustapusta · Mon, 13th-Jun-2011, 11:36 PM

Coinflip. Take a coin and flip it now. i call heads.

LennX · Mon, 13th-Jun-2011, 11:41 PM

okay. tails= citizen

time to randomly lynch mustapusta when nighttime is over and im still alive xD

cruxis · Tue, 14th-Jun-2011, 1:06 AM

You know guys, if you weren't so fast to lynch Aean, we could have gotten the name of the other mafia member. But now that's thrown out the window and we have very little post information to tie Deathsfang to anyone.

pikk0n · Tue, 14th-Jun-2011, 1:54 AM

Random lynching is more fun for us bystanders.

Also, if your scenario were to occur cruxis, this game would be over really quickly. No fun....

**HDPhoenix** · Tue, 14th-Jun-2011, 1:12 PM

Cruxis, you make it sound like we somehow knew that they were mafia related. The odds of one of the lovers being a mafia is 4/17, which is really low. I think its just really lucky we randomly picked off a mafia this early, blind

cruxis · Tue, 14th-Jun-2011, 1:30 PM

But we didn't even give them a chance to claim the lovers role. Plus, day lasts 48 hours. Why vote someone out in the first 6 hours?

Benji · Tue, 14th-Jun-2011, 1:41 PM

Actually it was 100% that a Lover was a Mafia, as I thought it would be a more interesting dynamic. Its a shame one got killed with the random lynch however

I'm looking at some of the other common rules used in the game, to see which roles would work best for future games (Like Joker and Lovers are this game).

Still waiting for the PM(s) from the 3 roles before next daytime (just to keep you guys updated).

cruxis · Tue, 14th-Jun-2011, 2:36 PM

Doctor and Role blocker. Doctor saves someone, and if that person is attacked, he lives.Role blocker stops any action that would have been done.

Next_rim · Tue, 14th-Jun-2011, 2:59 PM

Quote:

Actually it was 100% that a Lover was a Mafia, as I thought it would be a more interesting dynamic.

Not so sure it is a better dynamics. If citizens lynch any lover, they 100% lynch a citizen, so for citizens it's always a loss. Lover citizen has very slim chances of winning, because lovers have to kill all citizens, 2 other mafia, then lynch the 2nd mafia member, all while being stupidly vulnerable to random lynch, informant and vigilante.

Let's try a rapist and doctor next game. Rapist attacks some1 at night, and that person can't talk during daytime for 1 or 2 rounds, depending on rules. Makes defending or accusing so much more difficult.

Doctor, as mentioned above, calls a save each night. Can save both a mafia, or a citizen. Very interesting role.

Benji · Tue, 14th-Jun-2011, 3:09 PM

I am not going to have a 'rapist' in the game, if i were to have a Silencing character, it would be a Dentist or an Escort. I am actually leaning away from having such roles in the game as they slow the game down by blocking hits, and with the game already lasting several weeks, I don't think extending it helps. I won my first game of Mafia in 2003, so I understand how this game works.

And as for Lovers, they are on their own team, Citizens need to Lynch them to win the game, you don't actually lose a Citizen when they die, as they aren't working with you, they want everyone else to die (Citizens AND Mafia). If the citizens win, they obviously lose.

On a side note, please don't derail the thread with 'which roles do we want added'. Any suggested roles will be ignored.

mustapusta · Tue, 14th-Jun-2011, 4:24 PM

jeebus those mafia and informats are sure slow in handing in the report cards.

Benji · Tue, 14th-Jun-2011, 5:12 PM

Nighttime is over, and 2 players have been found DEAD!

SONATA has been killed by the Rossellini Family. He was a Citizen
nard has been killed by the Tortellini Family. He was a Citizen

1. Next_rim
2. Deathsfang - *DEAD* Killed by Lover (Tortellini Family/Lover)
3. BakaInu
4. cruxis
5. pokerface
6. Rorschach
7. SONATA - *DEAD* Killed by the Rossellini Family (Citizen)
8. Aean(: - *DEAD* Killed by Citizens (Citizen/Lover)
9. LennX
10. craZerk
11. Paroxysm
12. nard - *DEAD* Killed by the Tortellini Family (Citizen)
13. mustapusta
14. HDPhoenix
15. PoisoN
16. Zanderax
17. GGnoRe

It is now Daytime. Players have 48 hours to submit their vote for the day. Daytime will end in 48 hours or once all players have voted.

Zanderax · Tue, 14th-Jun-2011, 5:59 PM

Kill BakaInu

EveRorschach · Tue, 14th-Jun-2011, 6:00 PM

Alright, so...
Deaths was Tort family, leaving one left (yes?) Deaths voted for Musta (indicating Musta isn't the second Tort member), along with:
Crazerk
SONATA
HDPheonix
GGnore

Musta lives through a tied vote (we don't know how)
Overnight, SONATA (who voted for musta) dies. Along with nard.
Therefore, I think that musta is part of the Ross mafia.
And so I vote to lynch Musta!

PS. Now, nard was killed (who voted for Aean). So I'm going to assume that the one member left of Tort was not anywhere near elimination and so voted for a person who voted for a citizen to cover any clues. I also expect the second tort person to be Crazerk HDPheonix or GGnore.
Thoughts?