[x5.Crescendo]

Idea Two has some merit.

The regular BSG events are enough to scratch the competitive itch for us casual BSGs - if there is to be an additional BSG event, let it be completely different in every way.

I'd definitely agree with it being something more along the lines of fun and quirky themes, though perhaps not on a per-round basis. I'd suggest adopting a 'theme per event' instead so that folks don't miss out on the fun.

Another idea is having a selection of themes, randomly assigned to each player. Obviously this could potentially result in some very silly games.

Or even using Husky's Imba League map in the arcade to set up silly contests.

A round robin format (in either Bo1 or Bo3 depending on numbers) might be suitable to spread the madness around - the idea being that everyone gets an equal amount of games in.

For a secondary BSG event, I feel it'd be nice to have something where the fun is in getting in a bunch of silly games happening, and winning's just a nice bonus

Just bouncing ideas around to see what sticks