hacking is a very very serious accusation. it can absolutely destroy a players reputation and career, even if unproven, the stigma will stick around for a while. hence as tgun said there needs to more caution especially since chobo just won the masters cup, this is huge. if he is found to be hacking, of course he will be punished, have his wins and titles stripped and be banned from all tournaments etc. and that is a very big IF.
be neutral in the replay analysis - from what i've seen iaguz's was the only neutral one in the sense that it made a big effort to mention all the non-suspicious stuff as well. this is how analysis should be done, objective, neutral and giving the viewer full information and not skewing it to look like just one suspicious thing after the other.
everyone else's analysis was just mentioning the suspicious stuff and ignoring the moments that weren't like chobo's army walking straight into the baneling land mines, flying over pylons, not being prepared for the 6 lings, etc
the cr thing - the point chobo is trying to make is there is a lot of resentment now from certain people against him, which was apparent in his gaming set up thread. can you honestly say if he was in the team as cRchobo, would sensei and fourby have neg repped him for that thread? ask yourself that question. he would just be told civilly it was in the wrong thread. and this is related to this thread too because those some of that group that do not like him and are judging him already like he is guilty.
how you can help -
both sides please stop all these personal arguments right now. focus on the games and get the thread back on track
get anyone who has played against chobo to upload their replays against him. the replays you want are ladder / tournament games which he expects nobody to watch. start with the SEASL games there are bunch in the replay db I believe from the qualifiers and finals, so the replays are sitting there waiting to be analysed. if hes hacking sooner or later very strong incriminating evidence will surface, like what happened in the fadeevets thread. and if you do find very strong evidence that he does not hack too in those games, be fair and post about it.
the worse thing is for an innocent person to be accused of hacking or a crime he did not commit, so take caution, gather more evidence and reserve judgment till the undeniable evidence presents itself. you would not want the same thing happening to you or your friends either.
Even the smallest donations help keep sc2sea running! All donations go towards helping our site run including our monthly server hosting fees and sc2sea sponsored community tournaments we host. Find out more here.