I am a huge fan of your work. I want to thank you for the effort you have put in. If I may give my opinion on the "Unearth Talent" change which some people seem not to like. I feel it looks a bit too cartoony and less dark and dirty. Like it's suppose to be a zombie's hand but it doesn't look very zombie-like. Just my opinion.
This idea is also very easily built upon for the GPD medal and potentially Masters cup. Remember, constructive feedback is preferred (e.g. different background colour, silver rather than bronze, etc...)
Reasoning:
- Green in SC2 achievements usually indicates the lesser of the 2 achievements (e.g. Team rather than Solo) hence the green background choice.
- Bronze medal for the BSG league, Silver for the GPD league, Gold for higher competitions.
- Ribbon is in the colours of Bronze, Silver and Gold.
Also:
Golden Glory: Champion of a GPD, watch out for this player on his way to Master league glory.
Reasoning:
- Green in SC2 achievements usually indicates the lesser of the 2 achievements (e.g. Team rather than Solo) hence the green background for BSG and blue for GPD.
- Silver medal for the lesser of the 2 achievements and gold medal for the greater of the two.
- Ribbons show the colours of the league (BSG = bronze, silver and gold and GPD is gold, platinum (white) and diamond (blue)).
The idea isn't to improve it... it's to make all achievements match and look like a complete (smooth and not scrappy) set. For example the currently completed achievements look like they go together side by side:
I will consider re-doing the SCV as an alternative but please be advised that the achievements do not need to be solely SC2 themed any more due to the Diablo invasion.
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheGentleman
FaDeUndoNe: I prefer the old ones, my opinion though
I'm going to get a lot of mixed views regarding the homogenisation of these achievements. I kindly request that any comments you have on my work could be constructive. E.g. I prefer the old ones because... (and then fill in the blanks). Fact remains I will not be able to please everyone.
The Legionnaire: Any player who has spent time in the mecca of Starcraft, Korea - either as a competitor or spent the majoirty of their trip as a caster / spectator.
Amazing work so far. In my opinion, it's nice to have these new ones as a change. They brighten up the place more. Now if I could make some requests for the ones I feel should be changed as well,
1. Letters to Cleo - Awarded to the Scribes of SEA, who have produced quality content ranging from battle reports to articles or interviews.
2. The Gatekeeper - Awarded to dedicated members of the community who have taken the time to organise successful series of tournaments for the community.
3. Ayo Technology - Awarded to those who have helped sc2sea through the creation of banners, programming code and other funky techy stuff beyond the ability of us normal humans.
I think it is very nice what you are doing and I want more! As a side note, I disagree that it should all be starcraft themed. I feel our potraits are already starcraft themed so the achievements should look however they sound like. (if you know what I mean)
Finally got around to replacing my own achievement .
Ayo Technology: Awarded to those who have helped sc2sea through the creation of banners, programming code and other funky techy stuff beyond the ability of us normal humans.
SC2SEA Supporter! For helping to support SC2SEA through the purchase of Diablo 3 for a friend or for yourself! We thank you for your support!
The Cheese Shield: For winning the Cheese Shield Tournament.
Golden Glory: Champion of a GPD, watch out for this player on his way to Master league glory.
New Member of the Month: New achievement to encourage new posters / lurkers to start posting more.
Quality Member of the Month: New achievement to show appreciation to our quality posters and hopefully encourage others to make such posts too.
Community Builder: For recognition to those who have built the Starcraft 2 SEA community into what it is today.
The Legionnaire: Any player who has spent time in the mecca of Starcraft, Korea - either as a competitor or spent the majoirty of their trip as a caster / spectator.
Ayo Technology: Awarded to those who have helped sc2sea through the creation of banners, programming code and other funky techy stuff beyond the ability of us normal humans.
SC2SEA Supporter! For helping to support SC2SEA through the purchase of Diablo 3 for a friend or for yourself! We thank you for your support!
The Cheese Shield: For winning the Cheese Shield Tournament.
Golden Glory: Champion of a GPD, watch out for this player on his way to Master league glory.
New Member of the Month: New achievement to encourage new posters / lurkers to start posting more.
Quality Member of the Month: New achievement to show appreciation to our quality posters and hopefully encourage others to make such posts too.
Community Builder: For recognition to those who have built the Starcraft 2 SEA community into what it is today.
The Legionnaire: Any player who has spent time in the mecca of Starcraft, Korea - either as a competitor or spent the majoirty of their trip as a caster / spectator.
Ayo Technology: Awarded to those who have helped sc2sea through the creation of banners, programming code and other funky techy stuff beyond the ability of us normal humans.
The Gatekeeper: Awarded to dedicated members of the community who have taken the time to organise successful series of tournaments for the community.
Option 3: Easter egg added back in with better graphics and alternative background colour... the down side is the easter egg is only visible on the 75px image.
Even the smallest donations help keep sc2sea running! All donations go towards helping our site run including our monthly server hosting fees and sc2sea sponsored community tournaments we host. Find out more here.