[syfChadMann]

I check the SC2Ranks of every player against TA each week.. each manager should do this to weed out smurfs. BeTasoO also has barely played this season - if at all.
Additionally the matter has be brought up with the SEAL admins to review - where myself or Arnor will not have input into the decision.

Don't think it's biased because I take the time to check players before matches. BeTassO was a 1400 Diamond league player.. This is why he is being alleged as a smurf - not because he beat a Diamond player. I raised this issue with Arnor and Edarus before or shortly after the end of the first match between MarineFifty and BeTasoO.

EDIT, and Diamond players are not permitted to be subbed into this tournament - MarineFifty was plat when he signed up and was promoted. This being the crux of the issue regarding his legibility for this tournament - VB asked to sub in a Diamond player mid season and were denied, ZeroCraft should have the same rules applied to them.

[breadfan]

Originally Posted by TAChadMann

I check the SC2Ranks of every player against TA each week.. each manager should do this to weed out smurfs. BeTasoO also has barely played this season - if at all.
Additionally the matter has be brought up with the SEAL admins to review - where myself or Arnor will not have input into the decision.

Don't think it's biased because I take the time to check players before matches. BeTassO was a 1400 Diamond league player.. This is why he is being alleged as a smurf - not because he beat a Diamond player. I raised this issue with Arnor and Edarus before or shortly after the end of the first match between MarineFifty and BeTasoO.

EDIT, and Diamond players are not permitted to be subbed into this tournament - MarineFifty was plat when he signed up and was promoted. This being the crux of the issue regarding his legibility for this tournament - VB asked to sub in a Diamond player mid season and were denied, ZeroCraft should have the same rules applied to them.

Shouldn't we be looking at replays from the start of the season / when he joined the team then?

I mean, all that matters is if he legitimately dropped in skill from the previous season's 1400 dia to SEACL's start. If he did, then improved to dia level again, I don't see that as being any different to any other player who earned a dia promotion this season

[Volition]

Originally Posted by TAChadMann

Don't think it's biased because I take the time to check players before matches. BeTassO was a 1400 Diamond league player.. This is why he is being alleged as a smurf - not because he beat a Diamond player. I raised this issue with Arnor and Edarus before or shortly after the end of the first match between MarineFifty and BeTasoO.

My only question is why this has become an issue after a game win to ZC. Why wasnt this raised when you discovered it? Surely this should have been discussed during the day - not after a crucial game win to ZC and against TA.

Either way, i dont think it will matter. This is only the regular season after all - the playoffs are all that is coming

tier 5 has been great, really manner between every team. As the stakes got higher, so have the the tempers. This will all blow over in the morning, let's just everyone take the night off playing detective and posting.

GG minimat, you were way better than me tonight

Quick Comments

krycek:

finally some rep

[syfChadMann]

Originally Posted by Volition

My only question is why this has become an issue after a game win to ZC. Why wasnt this raised when you discovered it? Surely this should have been discussed during the day - not after a crucial game win to ZC and against TA.

LIke I said - the issue was raised before MarineFifty and beTasoO finished their games. It was only brought out publicly after the match had concluded.

[x5_Potter]

Originally Posted by TAChadMann

VB asked to sub in a Diamond player mid season and were denied, ZeroCraft should have the same rules applied to them.

I don't think that was us o.0

[syfChadMann]

Originally Posted by VB_Potthead

I don't think that was us o.0

It wasn't?.. I'm sure there were request to sub in players that were diamond and those requests were denied.

Regardless, Smoky has told me he is free Friday night or over the weekend..

ty!

[QEDFridge]

Originally Posted by TAChadMann

It wasn't?.. I'm sure there were request to sub in players that were diamond and those requests were denied.

Regardless, Smoky has told me he is free Friday night or over the weekend..

ty!

I inquired mid season whether the rules would allow a diamond sub, but I didn't TRY to. so whether you are referring to me?

Quick Comments

syfChadMann:

could be...