[Xeen]

No. If the player's opinion on the situation counts, then you're accepting that following the rules is optional based on what the player wants. You cannot have a situation with two different possible rulings because the players feel differently and still expect to have legitimacy in your rules.

In an organized competition, the role of the player is to play, anything beyond that needs to be handled by the admins for the sake of impartiality.

Quick Comments

	|Erasmus|:	Agreed... if the admin decision is that the rules require a regame... it doesn't matter what revenant is okay with.
	UHF:	This
	x5_dot:
	JaFF: