[Champi]

Originally Posted by Xeen

Players shouldn't come into it at all, this is an admin decision.

i disagree,

yes it is the admins decision, but theres no reason they should ignore the fact that the player who won on the illegitimate map is willing to accept that a mistake was made and will regame.

rules were broken, accidentally or not, and to deliberately not rectify the situation when the person who is at the disadvantage accepts a regame is retarded

[UHF]

Originally Posted by TAChampi

i disagree,

yes it is the admins decision, but theres no reason they should ignore the fact that the player who won on the illegitimate map is willing to accept that a mistake was made and will regame.

rules were broken, accidentally or not, and to deliberately not rectify the situation when the person who is at the disadvantage accepts a regame is retarded

I disagree. It's ok if both players are willing & able to regame AND the admin is willing to overrule his decision.

HOWEVER, you shouldn't rag on the admin if he doesn't want to overrule his decision.

(That is of course unless you don't want anyone adminning anymore for fear of the community belting you up if you don't change your rulings to popular opinion.)