[Next_rim]

I like your reasoning of vote patterns and post timing. I looked back, and noticed You and Yong could be Mafia, as you were both pretty quick to vote for Sonata.

Imagine you are mafia. Actually, don't have to imagine, I think you are mafia. So, you have only one ally, yongming, and have to vote for Sonata. You go ahead and say the entire population "I support yongming", giving a solid lead for others to consider both of you mafia. Then, during day 2, your ally has a 50/50 chance of being lynched. Then a person changes vote and puts an opponent up 4/3. So you change your vote and put your ally up 4/4 so he dies. Nice plan! Either you are bad at mafia game, or you are not mafia.

Imagine you are citizen who has to vote and give reason for a vote. You are lazy and don't care who to vote, so you just randomly pick a person and jump on his bandwagon. It's day 2 anyway, who cares?

Now suddenly, when yongming is starting to lead vote count, two people (who, including yongming, all voted different random people), jump in and bash zergtastic, second in-lead. Do I have to remind there is a 3-member mafia family still in game?

[cruxis]

Originally Posted by Next_rim

So, you have only one ally, yongming, and have to vote for Sonata. You go ahead and say the entire population "I support yongming", giving a solid lead for others to consider both of you mafia.

Can you please quote the post where I did this? I just looked, and haven't voted for Sonata, I voted for Zerg and Paroxym. I also can't see any post where I've supported Yongming. On day 2 i told Yong not to vote for him because there was a chance he was the vigilante. So trying not to get a citizen voted off is mafia behaviour???

Originally Posted by next_rim

Then, during day 2, your ally has a 50/50 chance of being lynched. Then a person changes vote and puts an opponent up 4/3. So you change your vote and put your ally up 4/4 so he dies. Nice plan! Either you are bad at mafia game, or you are not mafia.

I have no idea what you're saying here. Please rephrase what point you're trying to make.

Originally Posted by next_rim

Imagine you are citizen who has to vote and give reason for a vote. You are lazy and don't care who to vote, so you just randomly pick a person and jump on his bandwagon. It's day 2 anyway, who cares?

I would rather try and get a mafia then just keep randomly voting people until we get lucky.