[Meatex]

Originally Posted by Revenant

To be honest, I think their reasons against you have been more objective and logical than yours. You seem way too suss.

They all elaborated on their votes and picks, you just left it to "Oh my gut feeling"

honesty != suss
no remotely solid leads so all anybody had was their gut feeling, whether they rationalized it somehow doesn't change it.
I voted for Sang on my gut feeling because of how I felt about his posts.

Yes saying I may be mafia cause the one guy who voted for me, possibly because I was the person he knew the most so he picked me when everybody was just randomly picking is logical to an extent
I countered that saying that in no situation would killing him be beneficial to me if I was mafia. Drawing unwanted attention for no reason is silly.
Gentleman's counter to that is "why not" 0.o??
In that case why not any other person? Why not someone that wouldn't immediately bring attention to me? Thus chewbaca :P
There is something very suss going on with breadfan and gentleman

[breadfan]

Originally Posted by FaDeMeatex

honesty != suss
no remotely solid leads so all anybody had was their gut feeling, whether they rationalized it somehow doesn't change it.
I voted for Sang on my gut feeling because of how I felt about his posts.

Yes saying I may be mafia cause the one guy who voted for me, possibly because I was the person he knew the most so he picked me when everybody was just randomly picking is logical to an extent
I countered that saying that in no situation would killing him be beneficial to me if I was mafia. Drawing unwanted attention for no reason is silly.
Gentleman's counter to that is "why not" 0.o??
In that case why not any other person? Why not someone that wouldn't immediately bring attention to me? Thus chewbaca :P
There is something very suss going on with breadfan and gentleman

To be fair, if you are mafia, you know that Sorathez isn't in your family. Therefore, not being "beneficial" is false. Like I said, killing someone like Sorathez when it looks "too" obvious to be you is a pretty clever move.

There are 5 mafia among the 9 other people left in town. So the odds that you are mafia are fairly good.

Without chatting outside the game and revealing their roles to each other, I don't think the informant has revealed them self. Perhaps they dropped subtle hints, but nothing particularly stands out. Therefore, I don't think the informant is talking to the doctor, and I don't think Rev's being saved was based on any facts from the informant. So I'm hoping that putting myself out there catches attention, since clearly we aren't in a position where we can all role claim yet with mafia superiority.

Quick Comments

x5.Revenant:

Agree, the informant needs to step up if we want to win.

[breadfan]

Originally Posted by Revenant

Revenant: Agree, the informant needs to step up if we want to win.

Actually, I don't think so. That puts the informant at risk. By declaring myself the citizen (which the informant can verify), if the doctor saves me we can work at picking out the mafia. The doc can only save one person and anyone else revealing themselves before we have equal numbers would just mean mafia could basically all vote for that person and townies lose - they could even all say "Yep I been mafia whole time LOL" and it wouldn't matter. I'm definitely more expendable than the doctor, informant or vigilante, hence the role claim.

I have this bad feeling that Asrath is the survivor, which could be why she says townspeople would be sorry for being rid of her. We need the survivor voting with us right now to even up numbers.

Quick Comments

	Asrathiel:	Better hope souljah comes along and votes for not-me then! What happens if tie?
	x5.Revenant:	Its hard though, without being too obvious that the person himself is informant; Doc then protects him
	TheGentleman:	In a tie I think it comes down to a coin flip.