[x5.Revenant]

Let's have a look at the relevant Day Two's votes:

cRSanG = Voted for Revenant
TCPLemminks = Voted for Revenant
breadfan = Voted for Revenant
Asrathiel = Voted for Revenant

VB_Bandit = Voted for cRSanG
ToRSpartaz = Voted for cRSanG
Revenant = Voted for cRSanG
FaDeMeatex = Voted for cRSanG
cRfenner = Voted for cRSanG

With SanG known to be Mafia, it's not unwise to think that some of the people who voted alongside him without strong reasoning is with him. That's Lemminks, Asrathiel and breadfan. Lemminks was just known to be a citizen, which takes him out of the picture. This leaves us with Asrathiel and Breadfan. My Lannister intuition tells me that Asrathiel is more likely to be a mafia out of the two, because she offered to have physical contact with me in the form of:

Originally Posted by Asrathiel

Imma vote Revenant, but I'll give him a big hug first

and in the world we live in, getting hugged means there's a possibility of the person getting stabbed in the gut. This means that Asrathiel is the one more likely to be a Mafia.

I take my leave, I have a throne to sit.

[breadfan]

(quote in spoiler tag coz its a massive post)

+ Show +

Originally Posted by Revenant

Let's have a look at the relevant Day Two's votes:

cRSanG = Voted for Revenant
TCPLemminks = Voted for Revenant
breadfan = Voted for Revenant
Asrathiel = Voted for Revenant

VB_Bandit = Voted for cRSanG
ToRSpartaz = Voted for cRSanG
Revenant = Voted for cRSanG
FaDeMeatex = Voted for cRSanG
cRfenner = Voted for cRSanG

With SanG known to be Mafia, it's not unwise to think that some of the people who voted alongside him without strong reasoning is with him. That's Lemminks, Asrathiel and breadfan. Lemminks was just known to be a citizen, which takes him out of the picture. This leaves us with Asrathiel and Breadfan. My Lannister intuition tells me that Asrathiel is more likely to be a mafia out of the two, because she offered to have physical contact with me in the form of:



and in the world we live in, getting hugged means there's a possibility of the person getting stabbed in the gut. This means that Asrathiel is the one more likely to be a Mafia.

I take my leave.

That's a good point, and for me raises more suspicion about Asrath. I didn't pay much attention to what my voting in line with sang might imply. To justify it as my own decision - if you count the votes up to my vote, the tally should be something like Sang and Spartaz in the lead on 4 each, and with my vote for Rev I believe he was boosted to 4 also, creating a 3 way tie situation. The other two got votes after mine, but Rev did not. I was aiming for that tie (not that Rev hadn't already raised some suspicions, just that this was the reason why I chose him over a couple of other options I had, after my original vote for already-dead Paroxysm was useless). Earlier in the day, I very nearly voted SanG, and my posts reflect this. Honestly, it was that line about the role claiming that really sold it to me. I'll never trust that man again :P

I don't know how the tie breaker situation works, but I figured there was a good chance they'd all die, and I believe that with more kills, the greater the chance to kill a mafia, and the easier it will be to spot remaining mafia. While I'm still wary of Rev, my vote for him was of convenience that he happened to be trailing by a single vote.

I want to note that the same way that the aLterlegroes voting for Rogue the same as the ToRentinoes might be a reason for them not killing anyone Night 1, it's also possible that none of them actually sent their choice in. Meatex's "not following the game" fits with the latter. I was taken in by a pretty legit sounding SanG, so I'm not buying into Meatex's claims this time round.

Originally Posted by Meatex

He wasn't convincing anybody with his vote so there would be no reason to kill him as a mafia. Killing someone who isn't a threat where the only available link leading back to the person who killed him would be kinda silly

Or, you could have thought this through and chosen him for this reason, with the intention of playing this card if it were brought up to hide it.