SC2SEA.com - Starcraft 2 SEA eSports Community Site

breadfan · Sat, 23rd-Jun-2012, 9:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CombatEZ

I think we will just do walkovers but I will discuss it with the other admins later.

All the dates are getting pushed back one week as well so everything can be fully worked out and there is no rush.

OK well since we have time, I'll give my opinions from a player perspective

My vote is definitely to see every match get played wherever possible - I'd prefer reschedules in all cases rather than subs. I mean, sure there can be restrictions on subs so that the other team doesn't get disadvantaged, like either the sub must be a lower league than the player they replace, or the sub must be the same race. I'd really like it if every no-show was a default reschedule (which I think is the way it went in SEACL). There's inevitably the guy who loses power/internet drops out 15 mins before match time who just can't get on. While that sucks for his opponent who is online expecting a game, I think that person deserves the ability to basically pick the reschedule time rather than simply get a free win.

So player X is online waiting, his opponent player Y doesn't show. Y gets on and says "Sorry, crashed my car, had to get towed. I can play Monday 5pm, Tuesday 6pm or Wednesday 7pm". Player X gets the option to pick from all available times the one that best suits him, and if they can't agree, THEN player X gets awarded the walkover. It's not a perfect system, someone who really wants to take a w/o can just claim the times don't suit them, but I don't think many people have this kind of attitude, especially in the BSG tournament.

Winning by walkover isn't a fun way to win, and losing by walkover really stings everyone else on the team.

Heady · Sat, 30th-Jun-2012, 8:20 PM

NSW 3 - 2 WA

New South Wales vs Western Australia
Player	Map	Player
killself 2	WCS Antiga Shipyard	0 AsGNasch
livibee 0	WCS Tal'Darim Altar LE	2 EzDefault
Moonprentice 0	WCS Daybreak LE	2 azunyan
VBbandit 2	WCS Shakuras Plateau	1 Head
killself 2	WCS Cloud Kingdom LE	1 Dan

Quick Comments

VB_Blake:

wp

FSBenAD · Sat, 23rd-Jun-2012, 9:25 AM

Ah ok so Round 1 next weekend then?

If thats the case I'll resend my lineup, so you can ignore the one I sent, since I need to recheck who is available that weekend

FSBenAD · Sat, 23rd-Jun-2012, 9:41 AM

I agree with breadfan... I dont know how seriously everyone else is taking this, but I figure at our level we are playing for fun, and playing games rather then winning games is what its all about.

plus the fact that players are more casual at our level and there are guarenteed to be people who cant make it at the last minute each week.. I'd love to see a sub rule.

AsylumofSouls · Sat, 23rd-Jun-2012, 11:22 AM

Agreed with both posts above.
Also, the trouble I went to to organise players for this Sunday only to find it's been postponed is a little annoying... but probably for the best

FSBenAD · Tue, 26th-Jun-2012, 3:34 PM

So... have we got any more clarification on what the rules for subs etc will be?

Dont mean to be pushy, but it has a big affect on who I'll pick for the matches, if someone who doesnt turn up is a walkover

MezjE · Sat, 30th-Jun-2012, 9:43 AM

Posted PD Match ups for tonight, now editing dates thread!

ninja brett · Sat, 30th-Jun-2012, 10:14 AM

where can you find matchup ?

**TheGentleman** · Sat, 30th-Jun-2012, 11:16 AM

I'm slightly confused about the Victoria Vs. Territories matchup. Looks like some weird form of Copy and paste of the SA Vs. QLD one.

Quick Comments

AsylumofSouls:

Seems like it =\

AsylumofSouls · Sat, 30th-Jun-2012, 11:21 AM

Why you say you've only received the Qld BSG lineup when I sent mine already as well?
=\

FaDeHellfyre · Sat, 30th-Jun-2012, 6:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AsylumofSouls

Why you say you've only received the Qld BSG lineup when I sent mine already as well?
=\

I sent mine days ago too :/

ETL.ViTaL · Sat, 30th-Jun-2012, 12:19 PM

just to clarify round one will be starting at 7pm tonight (Sat 30th June) for the P/D SoO

ninja brett · Sat, 30th-Jun-2012, 1:57 PM

you have made a mistake with the maps, you said daybreak was game 3 but then it is change to game 4 ?

FSBenAD · Sat, 30th-Jun-2012, 6:56 PM

South Australia vs Queensland
Player	Map	Player
FSVulcan (1)	WCS Antiga Shipyard	Venom (2)
tbhVisions (0)	WCS Tal'Darim Altar LE	TheGentleman (2)
GuessWho (1)	WCS Shakuras Plateau	elimzkE (2)
honeybadger (2)	WCS Daybreak LE	TheGentleman (0)

QLD had no sub so I agree to let TheGentleman play twice,

MezjE · Sat, 30th-Jun-2012, 6:57 PM

Switching it up now, I c/p as I didnt have VIC line up but thought I changed TER... Was in a huge rush to get to ComicCon soz.

From now on please just PM me line ups... Skype I am having heaps of issues with.

ninja brett · Sat, 30th-Jun-2012, 7:29 PM

is this still happening next week, or are you gonna delay as everyone will be at ACL

MezjE · Sat, 30th-Jun-2012, 7:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ninja brett

is this still happening next week, or are you gonna delay as everyone will be at ACL

Good point! Most likely delay.

ToRVenom · Sun, 1st-Jul-2012, 9:18 AM

U know what i think Queensland is goign to take this away EZ.. Look at those scores... what ballers.

Quick Comments

AsylumofSouls:

Just wait for the BSG results mate

AsylumofSouls · Sun, 1st-Jul-2012, 11:39 AM

Considering games are tonight, can the OP please be updated with the match-ups so we know what to plan for?

Quick Comments

ToRVenom:

U seem so eager .. i dont know why its not like you have a chance.. only problem is we have GUNTER

Odras · Sun, 1st-Jul-2012, 12:06 PM

So what is happening with the BSG tonight? Is it going ahead? Do states have teams? It would be good if we could get an update on what was happening.